AJ in Chuuk

Tuesday, February 28, 2006

Some Cultural Differences

Something interesting about Lent which is coming up. Normally we Catholics give up meat on Fridays. However, that doesn’t make any sense in the islands. So at Sunday at mass Fr. Arthur told us that we’d be giving up rice. The students gasped. That makes more sense since we give should give up something big.

Also, I’m teaching SAT prep, and the new SAT has a section that involves essays. The principle gave me an SAT practice book, and I looked through all of the essays. Some of them are impossible for the Juniors to do. Not because they’re too hard, but they’re geared towards American society. Here is one example:

“Have professional sports influenced the values of American society?”

That one is obvious. Here is one that you may not understand would be hard for these Micronesian students to write about:

Quote: “A man walking down a crowded street noticed a dog lying by the side of the road that looked like it might be injured; but since everyone else just passed by, the man was satisfied to assume that the dog was fine. The next day he learned that the dog had been hit by a car and lay injured for two hours before a concerned man stopped and took it to the vet. The animal recovered, but the man never forgave himself for leaving it for someone else to help.”

Now, the assignment asks you to write a well developed and clear 400 word essay on your view on individual responsibility in the situation described above. To be fair, I’m sure most of the Juniors could figure how to find a point of view on individual responsibility. However, this is not fair for a Micronesian for two main reasons. 1) They do not treat dogs like pets here. They’re all over the islands, skinny, dirty, dying and not really treated well by anyone. Why would anyone even be concerned about a dog in the first place. 2) The idea of a vet is foreign to people here. The only real animal you would be concerned about is your pig, which is where they get most of their meat from. But each family takes care of their own pig, so they are the vet. Anyway, I thought that was an interesting cultural difference.

5 Comments:

At 4:28 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Very interesting blog, AJ! I love reading your observations! If you don't eat rice on Fridays, what are you going to eat???
Take care and stay well. Love, M

 
At 5:31 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

AJ's what interesting comments and insights you are offering us. Very perspicaicious. Would like to know what the Principal and the faculty decided to do. Good for you AJ's
Papa

 
At 9:05 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Hey AJ,
That's a good point about the SAT. I think there's a lot of unintentional bias in standardized tests even within the country, let alone beyond it. I had never even thought of the problems that would arise for international test-takers.

Hope all is well there. Miss you!

 
At 9:27 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

That's a really interesting point about American values in standardized tests. Do you think that the students should know about American values if they are going to be going to school here? I'm not saying they should adopt those values, but having an idea might help in some assimilation. And by assimilation I don't mean they have to completely assimilate, they should keep their own culture, but just be conscious of our culture. Oh, whatever. Pigs are funny.

 
At 1:45 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

I'm actually going to be tutoring for the SAT a few hours a week starting in April... what an interesting observation that is! Do you think that might be one of the resonss schools like HC chose to make SATs optional for applicants?

 

Post a Comment

<< Home